Joker: A Film That Will Shake You to the Core
My Review on Joker – *Spoilers ahead*
It’s been a while since I’ve written a film review on here, and that’s because the past few films I’ve seen haven’t been that fantastic. IT: Chapter Two – it was ok. Hustlers – meh! The Goldfinch – terribly disappointing with no direction or identity. Judy – great performance but lacked that special spark. Joker – now this is a film worth having some coffee talk over!
It’s quite rare for a film to have a profound impact on me. I can only think of a handful of films that have given me an out of body experience in the theater. Joker is now on that list of elite movies for me. From start to finish I was hooked and in awe. I felt physically uncomfortable during most of the film (in a good way I suppose) and was absolutely enthralled by the way Joaquin Phoenix delivered his performance as Arthur Fleck/Joker.
This film will easily be nominated during awards season. Will it win? That’s a whole different story. However, Joaquin Phoenix certainly has my vote for Best Actor in the 2020 Oscars. He poured his heart and soul into that performance and it showed. It’s a performance like his that makes me LOVE the art of acting in the first place. His best scene was when he danced on the steps as Joker for the first time. It was an incredible accomplishment as Joaquin non-verbally demonstrated his character’s full transformation into absolute madness. He did an amazing job in this moment, and now I want to learn that choreography.
I won’t go too much into the film’s scenes as you should experience the entire movie for yourself. However, let’s discuss the story’s polarizing thematic elements. People have been divided and vocal with their opinions regarding the film due to its violent and antagonistic themes. There is no protagonist or hero in this story, and we spend 2 hours watching a mentally ill man hit rock-bottom every several minutes. He is beaten 3 times – once by a group of teens, once by 3 drunk men on a subway train, and once by Thomas Wayne himself! Two of those times were due to his neurological disorder. He has a condition that when stressed, will make him laugh uncontrollably. Because he laughs at times when it’s not appropriate, people immediately judge and make fun of him. He even carries a card explaining his condition to people when it happens, and no one seems to care. This is a real condition people suffer from, and Joaquin spent hours researching what it’s like to possess it. Apparently, it is not a pleasant condition as it could greatly hurt your chest, vocal cords, and breathing. Joaquin did these forced laughs with absolute perfection. He captured all the emotions you would expect someone to have who’s trying to stop himself from having this “episode.” While laughing, you could see him grab his chest, grab his throat, express scared facial expressions when it wouldn’t stop, etc. This alone was an amazing feat to watch and it provided a whole new take on the Joker’s infamous laugh.
So already you’re starting to feel sorry for him and hate the people being downright cruel to Arthur Fleck. Now this is when it got interesting for me. When the 3 drunk men attack Arthur on the subway train, he pulls out a gun and defends himself by shooting all 3 men dead. One of the men only gets shot in the leg and attempts to flee Arthur. However, he makes it a point to walk up to the crawling man and shoot him 3-4 more times. The person next to me applauded when Arthur killed the first 2 men, and I think other people did too. This is the division people are discussing. How much empathy do you gain for a person before you realize the moral line has been crossed? When Arthur kills the first 2 men you think, “Good! He needed to defend himself in that brutal attack.” But when he kills the 3rd man you think, “Ummm okay – that wasn’t necessary, but I guess I’m still onboard with the whole ‘justice for Arthur’ thing.” This turning point in the movie certainly makes you wonder about the real-life violence this world is confronted with daily. You’re feeling empathy for Arthur, because we’re experiencing the story through his lens. But the 3 men are mourned deeply by the citizens of Gotham, because they don’t understand what led to their murders. So as an audience member you become conflicted. You know that violence is never the answer, but since you “witnessed” the events leading up to this point, you understand the motive better. So, does that make it right? Why did the stranger next to me applaud? Would he have applauded if he was watching this film through the perspective of Gotham City’s citizens and like them, learned about the murders with no added context? I would hope not. But this is the reason why this film is getting mixed reviews. People are worried the film justifies violent behavior and promotes it as a suitable and realistic solution when people are cruel to you. They are worried society will blame victims for provoking an act of violence instead of the responsible party. And with no Batman superhero to turn to for moral reassurance, Arthur Fleck is our new “clown vigilante” for the downtrodden.
While most people will appreciate the film for what it is, I can understand the concern regarding someone thinking this behavior is okay. When Arthur Fleck/Joker continues to kill more people, including his favorite late-night talk show host for berating him on live television, it leads to an absolute frenzy in the city of Gotham. People are following the Joker’s path and taking situations into their own hands. This is scary, because it’s portrayed in a way that makes you think about the possibilities of something like this occurring. And it all boils down to broken systems, a lack of compassion for others, governmental neglects, and mental illness.
This leads me to my next point – mental illness. I personally believe the film is trying to get us to have a conversation about mental illness and not so much about violence. Arthur Fleck is outstandingly troubled, and you witness how little the government/people care about him and those who need help. There were some crucial lines in this film that cut me like a knife:
- “I hope my death makes more sense than my life.”
- “You don’t listen do you doc? All I have are negative thoughts.”
- “The worst thing about having a mental illness is everyone expects you to behave as if you don’t.”
The 3rd line hit home with me as I’m sure it will hit home for many moviegoers. It is a true statement when compared to modern day society. Mental illness still has the stigma that you are weak, unworthy, and not capable. Many American workplaces claim to promote mental health awareness, but realistically don’t advocate for it. It’s much easier to call out of work with a cold than it is with depression – even in 2019. I believe the film is not promoting violent behavior, but instead telling us to be kind to people. Because you never know what battle someone may be fighting. All I could think about during this film was if 1 single person would give Arthur Fleck a speck of decency, respect, and kindness, he may have not become the Joker after all. And that’s the polarizing conversation we all need to have. Can we alleviate acts of violence with proactive empathy, compassion, and human spirit? I also believe this film is not promoting gun violence but illustrating how easy it is to obtain a gun despite one’s mental health. That’s a whole different topic that hits close to home for us too.
In conclusion, I didn’t necessarily find the film to be dangerous. I found the film to be an awakening to how we treat others, how we target serious mental health concerns, and how we look at access to guns. This joker was very different from other Joker portrayals. In The Dark Knight, Alfred described the Joker as someone who simply wanted to watch the world burn. But in this film, it seems the Joker’s “watch the world burn” mentality could’ve been avoided. Can the same be said for the real-life scenarios we see frequently? Does mental health and gun violence intertwine as much as this film suggests?
As I mentioned before, this film was astonishing and will easily be one of my all-time favorite films. It received one of the biggest awards a film could receive (The Golden Lion) when it premiered during the Venice Film Festival a few months ago. As a result, I do believe we’ll see this film nominated in several different categories during awards season. And it would be very deserving of them as the film is one big roller-coaster. You have no idea what’s going to happen next and Joaquin did a great job keeping you at the edge of your seat consistently. I do highly recommend it, even for those who are afraid of graphic violence. There is one scene when Arthur Fleck stabs a man in the neck and eye with long metallic scissors. This is the worst scene when it comes to blood and graphics. Everything else was done tastefully and without much graphic depiction. Enjoy!